Replying to tool
13:04, Wed 13 May
The patronising Vila cope is real.
I admire the ambition of the project, and welcome the investment into the city. For a club that has only had average league attendances of over 30k 10-times in it's entire history, and hasn't had a league attendance over 40k for more than 40 years, a 60k capacity is clearly quite a statement.
I also like the interior of the stadium - it is simple, but it has a compact Allianz Arena feel to it.
In that context, criticism of the exterior seems a bit unfair. However, I do feel that the chimneys lack authenticity. They play on the stereotype of a post-industrial city, from the perspective of someone who is not from there - like a Peaky Blinders theme park. The large openings cut through the base of the chimneys also contribute to this.
I suppose I am saying that I'm impressed by everything about the project other than the bit that Heatherwick has designed.
I'm sorry, I didn't realise that this was a Birmingham City FC fan's forum, I thought it was an architecture/ construction forum, and I'm surprised that you think that my post was anything other than even-handed. I mentioned both average attendances and individual attendances. Yes, I'm suggesting that if the demand existed, then average attendances would have been higher historically, and there would also have been pressure to increase the overall capacity. The Taylor Report did not uniquely affect St Andrews, it affected every ground in the country. The fact is that 30k has been a perfectly viable capacity for St Andrew's since then - the proposed stadium capacity is double that.
I'm not suggesting that demand will not grow. In the current climate West Ham for example have demonstrated that unprecedented average attendances can be achieved in the Premier League, with relative success and good/ improved facilities. All I'm saying is that 60k is ambitious given all of the historical data, but that it is an ambition that I admire.
I guess this begs the question: Why haven't so many other clubs (who have sustained premier league status, full capacity for every game, and a waiting list for tickets) not expanded, or not to the size that Birmingham are, (even without any of those benefits in place)?
Everton is the obvious one, Chelsea another.
What do they know that Birmingham are missing, or vice versa?
I don't expect anyone to know the answer to this BTW, it's the headscratcher that every football fan who has seen this proposal is querying.
Not quite as West Ham had an outlay of peanuts for their stadium, it was basically a gift. It's revenue is only required to meet the running/maintenance costs.
Knighthead/Shelby (whoever is funding this project) will need a ROCE. Knighthead are venture capitalists specialising in distressed credit and real estate, they are investing money on behalf of their clients. It's not an Abramovich/Mansoor hobby project.
It has taken Wembley the best part of 20 years (46 major events a year (now permitted 54), 90k capacity, premium prices) to pay off £800 million. The Birmingham Sports Quarter is costing up to £3 billion (the stadium its self around £1.2 billion).
They must have a plan - but they haven't disclosed this from what I have seen. NFL has been mentioned, but the number of games would be small. Latest I have seen is that they have invested in 'The Hundred' cricket and Rugby has been mentioned. That is not going to be enough either.... Concerts are a money spinner but would be limited to the summer/off season, therefore only a handful per year at best.